Connect with us

Andrea Hill

Andrea Hill: Busting the Myths of Sales Made Through Social Media




Andrea Hill: Busting the Myths of Sales Made Through Social Media

Despite constant study of and reporting about social media sales, there continues to be misunderstanding about how social media really works and what expectations we should have of it.

Social Media Sales are Secondary. Prospecting and Awareness Building are Primary

Sure, in the beginning there was tremendous excitement about how social media would level the playing field for small businesses. It was free, and it was the answer to small business sales.

Only it wasn’t. And it isn’t.

So when I see quotes that speak to analyzing the success of your social media efforts based on the number of sales, I cringe. Because that direct relationship doesn’t exist and can’t be readily measured.

Social Media Should be Analyzed like Display Advertising

What is exciting about social media is that if you throw a lot of elbow grease at it, you can create a very large social media following. On Twitter, this means at least 10,000 followers and on Facebook this means at least 5,000 followers. Those aren’t goals – those are minimum standards necessary to compete (to learn more about how to think about social media, click here).


Before social media, only large companies could afford to run display advertising in consumer magazines and commercials on television with sufficient coverage to create genuine consumer awareness. But no company ever claimed that it knew how many sales were driven directly by its Super Bowl commercial. Why? Because advertising isn’t measured in that manner (see this article in AdAge about the way Super Bowl ads are measured and thought about).

Then Why Advertise?

It is fairly common for companies to complain that they can never tell if their advertising is working. As a result, many small business owners refuse to advertise. This is unfortunate, because the failure to advertise equates to a failure to go fishing for new customers – which is called prospecting. One way or the other, all businesses must look for new customers.

We do know that companies and products with higher visibility and industry/consumer awareness have higher sales. This is one of the longest studied and benchmarked aspects of the advertising/marketing industries over many decades. Social media appears to have a similar effect as display advertising in magazines and on TV – it makes a brand or a product more familiar, so people are more likely to buy when an offer occurs. But just as when an advertiser runs an ad on TV the phones don’t automatically start ringing, when you add a buy link on Facebook the clicks don’t necessarily happen either. So what do we measure?

We monitor relative increase in consumer awareness to the relative increases in sales.

We measure the effectiveness of sales efforts to those prospects by measuring:

  • Percentage of quality prospects
  • Average number of contacts required to convert prospects to customers
  • Time lapse between acquiring prospects and converting them

If your prospecting efforts improve when using Social Media, then Social Media is working for you. These are just the metrics for monitoring prospecting success on Social Media. There are many other metrics for analyzing Social Media success, but that’s a different article.


Creating Emotional Connection

Social Media has a secondary benefit which has a cousin in the display advertising world. First, think about how feel-good commercials make you feel about a brand. When Coca-Cola sings about inclusiveness, when the Ford spokesman acts like your next-door neighbor, when Flo at Progressive Insurance makes us laugh, we develop warm feelings for the brand. This is a very specific advertising method designed to improve consumer brand engagement through an emotional connection.

Social media has an even more tangible engagement effect, because you can improve brand engagement with an emotional connection built on actual, authentic engagement. It requires commitment, but it works.

It’s About the Sales Cycle, not the Sale

Remember how the Sales Cycle works?

Prospecting: Get prospects’ attention, capture leads, establish your credibility as a brand.

Cultivating: Bond with your prospects, sort the more interested and likely from the less interested and likely, and create desire for your products.

Servicing: Close the sale, service customers, and deepen customer relationships.


Rinse, Repeat: You will likely lose 14% of your customers each year, so this process never ends.

Just as it can take many months or even years for a display advertising campaign to pay off in actual awareness, so does it take many months and even years for a Social Media strategy to pay off in actual awareness. Luckily for small business owners, the economics of social media are easier on the budget.

So remember: You don’t have to do Social Media. But you must market and promote and seek new prospects on a constant basis, and the economics of prospecting on Social Media are extremely advantageous for small business. But if you decide to use Social Media as part of your advertising and marketing strategy, don’t think you can measure its effectiveness with a direct relationship to sales. That will only lead to disappointment and discontinuation of a medium that – if you’re using it correctly – is providing a different set of important – and measurable – benefits.

Andrea Hill is a business owner and writer. She owns Hill Management Group, LLC, with the brands StrategyWerx and SupportWerx. StrategyWerx is Andrea’s platform for serving small business owners. Learn more at

This article is an online extra for INSTORE Online.



This Third-Generation Jeweler Was Ready for Retirement. He Called Wilkerson

Retirement is never easy, especially when it means the end to a business that was founded in 1884. But for Laura and Sam Sipe, it was time to put their own needs first. They decided to close J.C. Sipe Jewelers, one of Indianapolis’ most trusted names in fine jewelry, and call Wilkerson. “Laura and I decided the conditions were right,” says Sam. Wilkerson handled every detail in their going-out-of-business sale, from marketing to manning the sales floor. “The main goal was to sell our existing inventory that’s all paid for and turn that into cash for our retirement,” says Sam. “It’s been very, very productive.” Would they recommend Wilkerson to other jewelers who want to enjoy their golden years? Absolutely! “Call Wilkerson,” says Laura. “They can help you achieve your goals so you’ll be able to move into retirement comfortably.”

Promoted Headlines

Most Popular