JoEllen Jewelers Inc., Mendham, NJ

OWNER: JoEllen Jewelers Inc.; ADDRESS: 2 Hilltop Road, Mendham NJ 07945; PHONE: 973-543-9989


WHEN JOELLEN MENDHAM first saw what was to become her third jewelry outlet, it looked more like a building that should be condemned than one worthy of preserving. But she took on the historical property nevertheless, and now it’s become her pride and joy – and it even got a write-up in the local paper!

What’s the history of the building? How did you find out about it?

The store is over 133 years old, and was once the local post office, as well as having been a clock shop, a dressmakers, an ice-cream parlor, a furnishings store, a hairdressers and the Hedgehog Gift Shoppe. “I passed by every day, and one day saw an ad in the window to lease,” says JoEllen. “It had been empty for many years.”

Advertisement

How was the building adapted?

“As it was a historical building,” expalins JoEllen, “the changes that could be made were very limited.” The renovation was undertaken by a local builder, Grant Homes, who tried to retain as much of the building’s character as possible. But it was in dire need of restoration, as JoEllen observed when she first saw the site two years ago: “It looked more like a haunted house with dirt everywhere along with cobwebs and fallen beams. The whole back part of the building had been condemned.”

What’s the most unique feature of the store?

“The fireplace in the main room,” says JoEllen, “and the furniture, that makes it feel warm and comfortable.”

Please describe the interior of the store.

Advertisement

“The front room has a view of the street and has two glass towers with shelves to display jewelry, and 3 wooden pieces of furniture to display giftware. Plus a chair for my clients to relax in.

“In the main room, in front of the original fireplace, there are more display cases and two more chairs. There’s also an antique desk for sales staff.”

How doe people react to the store?

“They’re usually very surprised,” says JoEllen, “and they love the comfortable and homey feeling.” She no doubt adds to that warm welcome herself, adding, “I love the feeling that I am home and have friends stopping by – both old and new ones!”

PHOTO GALLERY (3 Images)
{{gallery_holder}}

INSTORE Staff

Over the years, INSTORE has won 80 international journalism awards for its publication and website. Contact INSTORE's editors at editor@instoremag.com.

Recent Posts

45 Year Old Venus Jewelers Closes Door, Moves to New Location

Venus Jewelers is hosting a store closing liquidation sale with savings of up to 70%…

2 days ago

Ring Bear Teams Up with MLB Star Austin Riley for Exclusive Wedding Ring Collection

This exciting collaboration brings together Ring Bear's jewelry expertise with Riley's personal style, interests, and…

2 days ago

AGS and GIA Announce Joint Event for September 2025

‘Converge’ brings together AGS Conclave and GIA Symposium.

2 days ago

Majority of Businesses Still Rely on Cash Payments: Survey

Despite the popularity of digital payments, almost six out of 10 businesses except to never…

2 days ago

From New Equestrian-Inspired Styles to a Line that Benefits Ukraine, Here Are the Latest Jewelry Collections

And don’t miss the latest Citizen watch from the Blue Angels collection.

2 days ago

10 Tips For Trunk Show Success

Manos Phoundoulakis offers advice for extraordinary events.

2 days ago

This website uses cookies.