True Tales

This ‘Crazy Eddie’-Style Ad Campaign Was a Crazy Mistake

The jeweler pulled the ads after only five days.

Published

35 seconds ago

January 29, 2026

INSTORE Staff Instore February 2026 Issue

This ‘Crazy Eddie’-Style Ad Campaign Was a Crazy Mistake

The ad was a hit — for about five days. IMAGE: GENERATED BY ENVATO AI

In this month’s survey, we asked the Brain Squad: Tell us about a business decision so spectacularly wrongheaded you still cringe years later. Here was our favorite story — to be published in the February 2026 edition of INSTORE magazine.

A JEWELER IN THE NORTHEAST ran TV ads with a special “Nothing is going to cost you an arm and a leg” sale, and we thought, why not try THAT? So, in a “Crazy Eddie” style of hyped-up delivery, I held up and waved a prosthetic arm and leg while touting that nothing storewide would cost an arm and a leg. It was tongue-in-cheek. Funny, tacky, and immediately successful. That’s the good news. The bad news? After five days, we had to pull the TV, radio, and print ads. We had received numerous calls from individuals and organizations saying it was disrespectful to veterans who suffered war-related injuries and people with serious medical issues. — Dennis P., Johnstown, PA

What’s the Brain Squad?

If you’re the owner or top manager of a U.S. jewelry store, you’re invited to join the INSTORE Brain Squad. By taking one five-minute quiz a month, you can get a free t-shirt, be featured prominently in this magazine, and make your voice heard on key issues affecting the jewelry industry. Good deal, right? Sign up here.

INSTORE Staff

Since launching in 2002, INSTORE has won 89 international journalism awards for its publication and website. Contact INSTORE's editors at [email protected].

click to Comment(Comment)

Don't Miss

7 More Mistakes Jewelers Wish They Could Undo

Honoring a Legacy: How Smith & Son Jewelers Exceeded Every Goal With Wilkerson

When Andrew Smith decided to close the Springfield, Massachusetts location of Smith & Son Jewelers, the decision came down to family. His father was retiring after 72 years in the business, and Andrew wanted to spend more time with his children and soon-to-arrive grandchildren. For this fourth-generation jeweler whose great-grandfather founded the company in 1918, closing the 107-year-old Springfield location required the right partner. Smith chose Wilkerson, and the experience exceeded expectations from start to finish. "Everything they told me was 100% true," Smith says. "The ease and use of all their tools was wonderful." The consultants' knowledge and expertise proved invaluable. Smith and his father set their own financial goal, but Wilkerson proposed three more ambitious targets. "We thought we would never make it," Smith explains. "We were dead wrong. We hit our first goal, second goal and third goal. It was amazing." Smith's recommendation is emphatic: "I would never be able to do what they did by myself."