SELLING DIAMONDS ISN’T just a retail transaction; it’s a high-stakes game of psychology, optics, and emotion. To dominate the showroom floor, you need to stop acting like a clerk and start acting like a consultant. Jewelry pros from across the country share their secrets to moving more carats and closing the deal every time.
Master the “Two-Diamond” Power Play: Don’t overwhelm your client with a tray full of options. Beth Greene of Conti Jewelers in Endwell, NY, suggests a streamlined approach: show loose diamonds just two at a time on a plain white background. Ask the customer which they prefer and why — is it the color, the cut, or the size? Play this “game” for no more than three rounds. Once they settle on one, confidently reassure them they have chosen “their” diamond. “This process… forced the sales associates to stop talking and just observe,” Greene said.
Run Your Pre-Game Prep: The sale starts long before the vault opens. Denise Oros of Linnea Jewelers in La Grange, IL, says building rapport is the foundation of every high-ticket sale. If a client calls ahead, use that “pre-game” time to ask open-ended questions about preferred metals, stone shapes, and the milestone being celebrated. This allows you to prepare intentionally and elevate the in-store experience from the moment they walk in.
Get the Gear in Their Hands: The glass display case is your biggest obstacle. “The only thing between us and a sale is a piece of glass sometimes,” says Allison Love of Allison Love’s Fine Jewelry in Rock Hill, SC. Bring the piece out and let them try it on. Take it a step further by putting a loupe in the customer’s hand. Jeff Markman of Markman’s Diamonds in Knoxville, TN, notes that letting them experience the quality difference through the lens makes the sale real.
Advertisement
Hustle Your Aged Inventory: Don’t let “old” stock gather dust. Amy Hunnefield of Pickett Brothers Jewelers in Jacksonville, FL, uses a “Green Tag Special” for inventory over a year old. Her team thinks creatively, often pulling gemstones from these pieces to create custom jewelry within 24 hours. Having a jeweler on hand to do immediate work can turn aging inventory into a fresh, bespoke sale.
Sell the “Tiny Chandeliers”: Diamonds are the ultimate ROI because of their versatility. Angela Cisneros of Angela Cisneros Jewelry Concierge in Atascadero, CA, compares them to “the color black” because they can be dressed up or down for daily wear. To close the deal, romance the science of the sparkle. Ellie Thompson of Chicago describes an ideally cut diamond as a collection of “tiny chandeliers” that break light into spectral hues.
The Bottom Line: If it sparkles, it sells. Keep your own jewelry immaculate because clients notice. Above all, bring the energy. “Love your job selling jewelry,” says Barry Fixler of Barry’s Estate Jewelry. When you combine passion with these pro tactics, you don’t just sell a stone — you sell a masterpiece.
