Connect with us

Headlines

Woman Must Return $40,000 Engagement Ring to Ex, Court Rules

It features a 3-carat stone.

mm

Published

on

Woman Must Return $40,000 Engagement Ring to Ex, Court Rules

A judge in Manhattan has ruled that a woman must return her $40,000 engagement ring to her ex fiancé.

Rodney Ripley gave the ring to Jennifer Rutten in 2011, but the wedding never occurred, the New York Post reports.

The couple broke up, but Rutten was reluctant to give the ring back when Ripley asked for it. The newspaper described the piece as “a 3-carat cushion-cut stone set in a Tacori ring.”

She and her attorney made several arguments in court, including a claim that the Manhattan court lacked jurisdiction because she’d moved to Milwaukee. Ripley, 54, and Rutten, 50, both lived in New York when they got engaged.

In the end, Ripley was granted a motion for summary judgment. New York law says that if the marriage didn’t occur, the ring has to be given back, according to the Post. Rutten also has the option of paying Ripley the value of the ring.

Justice Robert Reed of New York State Supreme Court wrote: “Here the undisputed facts show that the ring was given in contemplation of marriage and that marriage did not occur. Thus, Ripley is entitled to the return of the ring.”

Advertisement

Read more at the New York Post

Over the years, INSTORE has won 80 international journalism awards for its publication and website. Contact INSTORE's editors at [email protected].

Advertisement

SPONSORED VIDEO

Thinking of Retirement? This Jeweler Went for the Company That Shares His Values

Richard Frank of Goldstein’s Jewelry in Mobile, Ala., had worked in his family’s store since he was 13-years old. As its owner, he was proud to be at the helm of Mobile’s oldest jewelry store, an AGS, IJO and RJO member business. But there comes a time in every jeweler’s life when a decision must be made regarding the future. And for Frank, that meant turning the store over to new owners. He chose Wilkerson to handle the sale, a decision, he says, made a long time ago. “Their reputation is such that all the things we value are what they value,” he says. And the results surpassed Frank’s own expectations. Would he recommend Wilkerson for other jewelers who are considering a going-out-of-business or retirement sale? “If you’re contemplating a sale to maximize the return on your business, there is no one else in the industry that I could even think of recommending.”

Promoted Headlines

Most Popular